25 September, 2020

Art of khat vs art of writing

I REFER to the talk over the coaching of calligraphic writing, or khat, as a part of the Bahasa Melayu issue for Year Four students in government colleges from 2020. I have no objection in opposition to the Education Ministry for introducing calligraphic writing or any other writing. But is it a necessary inclusion in a language magnificence where the point of interest ought to be on writing? What is crucial for a ten-year antique student looking to hold close a language is the capacity to construct sentences, to realise, and to put in writing coherently, logically, always. As a lot as reading, writing is a essential skill to literacy. The number one level is vital in laying the inspiration for desirable writing skills. Language improvement in the early training years will make certain youngsters amplify their vocabulary, construct words in particular ways, grow to be familiar with primary linguistic canons, and eventually end up articulate speakers. This but can’t be completed in the learning of Bahasa Melayu if the khat is added, as this would overcomplicate and in the long run defeat the complete reason of language learning.

The ministry needs to recognize that writing is a form of art that develops through a focused technique. It is useless to forcibly in shape khat into the coaching of Bahasa Melayu, when the purpose isn’t to create a Renaissance Man, however instead to make certain affordable development of linguistic potential most of the college students. I am certain everybody is ambitious to see our kids turning into a polymath. But even this can’t be completed without getting to know the simple aspects of a language. I accept as true with the implementation of khat could be an abrupt change of direction from the setup focus on the coaching of Bahasa Melayu. Considering that a commonplace script has been evolved to study and write the language, the implementation of khat as a further script is an unnecessary confusion, especially for the primary college students who might be of their early life.

In that context, it’s miles important for us to wind lower back the clock once more to apprehend the nature of the training itself. Jean Jacques Rousseau, the Enlightenment scholar of 18th century Europe, recommended in his treatise entitled Emile, or On Education, that a child has to be left to research what they like consistent with their hobby and must not gain knowledge of a subject that they dislike. His mind had been reflected inside the faculty curriculums at that time. The European context won’t be suitable in the case of Malaysia, however, their achievements have however proved why the western world is leading the field of education. My inspiration is, consequently, that khat must be made a non-obligatory challenge inside the first instance to assess the extent of interest college students could have for the subject.

My actual concern is with how the creation of khat could affect the progress of Tamil schools. Research has proven Tamil school students do not carry out well on the secondary level. Prof N. S. Rajendran’s take a look at entitled “Status of Tamil School Education in Malaysia and Future Prospects”, in Contemporary Malaysian Indians, ed., Denison Jayasooria and K.S. Nathan, Kita (2016), truly suggests that many may want to still no longer write and study, even after spending six years at the primary stage. From the studies conducted on the 523 Tamil number one schools, college students are visible to were appearing nicely in arithmetic, science, and Tamil, but not so in Bahasa Melayu. It becomes discovered that 30% of them continually fail in Bahasa Melayu. Pushing khat through the Bahasa Melayu syllabus, I worry, may additionally considerably backfire within the case of Tamil college students. The failure quotes will very probable soar as much as the secondary stage. I additionally consider that it will be a burden for the teachers in the Tamil faculty to pick out up something definitely new to train. And this brings into question whether or not or not there may be sufficient instructors with the required information to be deployed across vernacular colleges.

Moving on to the importance of language, I would love to share my enjoy of supervising undergraduates and postgraduates for the beyond twenty years. Let me be frank, most of them are not able to write down intelligibly. More stunning is a number of them are government servants, lecturers from teacher education colleges and even instructors who are recipients of Guru Cemerlang. They frequently warfare to write a coherent paragraph and their sentences at instances have no logic. I suppose this is all due to the inherent weaknesses of our training device. If only that they had obtained proper grounding in language and writing from the primary stage itself, I agree with most lecturers like myself would now not were encountering problems in reading through manuscripts. The pressured inclusion of khat into the Bahasa Melayu syllabus subsequent yr should contribute not anything however an in addition decline in the degree of Malay writing capabilities.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *